What Would You Have Done?

History doesn't wait for observers. It demands participants. Step into the shoes of those who shaped the world—and face their impossible choices.

↓ EXPLORE THE DECISIONS

Choose Your Moment

1863 ⚖️

Abraham Lincoln

The Emancipation Question

War rages. Your cabinet is divided. The Emancipation Proclamation could win the war—or lose it. What do you do?

Click to enter this moment →

The Situation

It is July 1863. The Civil War has raged for two years, and the tide has finally turned. Union victories at Gettysburg and Vicksburg have shattered Confederate hopes, but the cost has been staggering—170,000 American lives lost, with more bleeding every day.

Your cabinet is split. Secretary of State William Seward urges you to issue the Emancipation Proclamation—transforming this from a war to preserve the Union into a moral crusade against slavery. This could win European sympathy and undermine the Confederacy's labor force. But Treasury Secretary Salmon Chase warns: border states will revolt. Northern Democrats will abandon you. The war could be lost.

The British are watching. Napoleon III in France is itching to intervene on the Confederacy's behalf. Your decision will echo across centuries.

The Choice You Face

Your Decision

Do you sign the Emancipation Proclamation—freeing slaves in rebel states and transforming the war's meaning? Or do you preserve the Union through compromise, potentially accepting slavery's continuation? What would you have done?

What Actually Happened

January 1, 1863

Lincoln signed the Emancipation Proclamation. It didn't free a single slave in Union states, but it transformed the war and prevented European intervention. The 13th Amendment eventually abolished slavery entirely. But Lincoln never saw the peaceful reconstruction he dreamed of—John Wilkes Booth assassinated him in 1865.

What would you have done?

[Sound: Quill on parchment, distant cannon fire, clock ticking]

1940 🦁

Winston Churchill

Britain Stands Alone

France is falling. America won't intervene. Hitler offers peace. Do you negotiate with the devil—or fight on alone?

Click to enter this moment →

The Situation

It is May 1940. The German Blitzkrieg has crushed France in six weeks. British Expeditionary Forces are retreating from Dunkirk, having abandoned their equipment on the beaches. France will surrender within weeks. Italy has declared war.

Hitler extends an olive branch: peace is possible. Your own Foreign Secretary, Lord Halifax, argues for negotiations. Why throw away British lives? The Empire could survive. America might come around eventually.

But you know what Nazi peace means. You've seen the concentration camps. You've read Mein Kampf. The question is: can Britain survive alone against the Wehrmacht's might?

The Choice You Face

Your Decision

Do you negotiate with Hitler—a man you despise—to preserve Britain? Or do you refuse, knowing it means years of war, bombing, starvation, and possible defeat? What would you have done?

What Actually Happened

June 4, 1940

Churchill gave his "We shall fight on the beaches" speech. Britain stood alone for a year, surviving the Blitz. The United States entered after Pearl Harbor. Churchill's refusal to negotiate is now celebrated as the moment Western democracy refused to bow to fascism.

What would you have done?

[Sound: Air raid sirens, typewriter clacking, distant explosions]

1945 ☢️

J. Robert Oppenheimer

The Father of the Atomic Age

The Trinity test succeeded. You created the bomb. Now you must decide: speak up about its future—or stay silent?

Click to enter this moment →

The Situation

July 16, 1945. The Trinity test has just succeeded in the New Mexico desert. The first atomic explosion in history has lit up the morning sky. You are now the father of the atomic age.

You quoted the Bhagavad Gita: "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." But the weapon isn't just theoretical anymore. Within weeks, it will be used on Japanese cities. You've heard the targeting committee discuss "-pyrotechnics"—the effects of burning cities.

You have access to President Truman. You could warn him about the arms race to come. You could advocate for international control of atomic energy. Or you could retreat into academic silence and let the politicians decide.

The Choice You Face

Your Decision

Do you speak up—risking your security clearance, your reputation, your career—to warn about the bomb's future? Or do you stay silent, letting history unfold without your voice in the room? What would you have done?

What Actually Happened

Post-August 1945

Oppenheimer initially supported using the bomb, then grew to regret it. He later opposed the hydrogen bomb and advocated for international atomic control. In 1954, his security clearance was revoked during the McCarthy era. He became a symbol of scientific conscience—and tragic persecution.

What would you have done?

[Sound: Desert wind, scientific equipment beeping, heavy breathing]

1963 ✊🏿

Martin Luther King Jr.

The Birmingham Campaign

Bull Connor's dogs. Fire hoses. Children's march. Do you escalate with direct action—or negotiate for scraps?

Click to enter this moment →

The Situation

It is April 1963. You are in Birmingham, Alabama—the most segregated city in America. For weeks, you've led protests against segregation. Your supporters—many of them children—have faced police dogs, fire hoses, and beatings. The world is watching.

President Kennedy's people are pressuring you to stop. "You're hurting the cause," they say. A negotiated settlement is possible—some integration, some promises. But will it be enough? If you accept a compromise, you betray the movement. If you escalate, more people will suffer.

You've just been arrested. From your cell, you wrote the famous "Letter from Birmingham Jail"—defending nonviolent resistance. But the question remains: direct action or negotiation? Confrontation or patience?

The Choice You Face

Your Decision

Do you escalate the Birmingham campaign—risking violence against children and your own life—to force national attention? Or do you negotiate a partial victory and live with the compromises? What would you have done?

What Actually Happened

May 1963

King escalated the campaign. Images of police brutality—dogs, hoses, beatings—shocked the nation. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 followed. Birmingham became a turning point. But King was assassinated five years later, in Memphis, still fighting for economic justice.

What would you have done?

[Sound: Chanting crowd, water hoses, distant gospel hymn]

1997 🍎

Steve Jobs

The Second Coming

Apple is dying. Microsoft wins. Do you return to save the company you built—or let it fail with dignity?

Click to enter this moment →

The Situation

It is 1997. You were fired from Apple twelve years ago. Since then, the company has been bleeding—market share collapsed, product lines are a mess, and Microsoft dominates everything. Apple has $2 billion in the bank but no direction. The stock is moribund.

You've been building NeXT and Pixar. You're not sure you want to return. Apple board member Ed Woolard calls: "You have to come back. Apple's going to die." They offer you the CEO job—but you know what it means. You'll have to gut the company. Fire people. Make enemies.

You could walk away. Let Apple die. Focus on your films and your next act. Or you could return to the company you founded, knowing you'll have to make brutal decisions.

The Choice You Face

Your Decision

Do you return to Apple—knowing it means firing friends, killing products, and fighting for control? Or do you let Apple fade into history, preserving your legacy as its founder but not its executioner? What would you have done?

What Actually Happened

September 1997

Jobs returned as interim CEO. He killed the Newton and other failing products. He cut 70% of the staff. He negotiated a $150 million investment from Microsoft. Then came the iMac, iPod, iPhone, and iPad—transforming Apple into the world's most valuable company. He died in 2011, a legend.

What would you have done?

[Sound: Keyboard typing, computer fan whirring, phone ringing]

Start Your Own Decision Journal

Every choice shapes history. Document your own pivotal moments—the decisions that defined who you became.

Begin Your Journey